For the sake of argue then. Thread unlocked.
Well in the netherlands it cannot be illigal if you download games, movies, software or music.
We have an organisation called BUMA who makes sure that copyrights are payed. And we pay in several ways:

We pay for the copyrights when we go to the movies

We pay for the copyrights when we by an original in strore

We pay for the copyrights, when we purchase empty DVD disk.

We pay for the copyrights (a percentage) in our internet /TV subscribtion
We are allow to use copies for own use only. I am not allowed to share my copies or distribute them:

On the internet

Give copies to friemds / family

In front of an audiance
So from my point of view, nothing illigal is happening.
However this is an international community, created by an citzin of the USA.
By my knowledge we have to stick to USA laws (right?).
I doubt it that the FBI will raid Tubesteak, but still I think we should respect the law.
On another note, I picked up a copy of BF2 for just 7 Euro.
If you take some effort the bargins are there. And if it is not available in your country, I am sure there are members you can work something out with to obtain a key.
discussion is open